deputations on the zoning amendment application for 19 Dundonald Street, a pilot patio program for Flying Monkeys Brewery
Minutes: not yet available
Watch Again: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DWE9jsX0fbQ
Agenda: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=A&ID=1244938&GUID=34F4BE31-9CAA-4EF3-A206-8303B7450FE4
Meeting Location: Council Chambers or online
ABSENT: Mayor Nuttall (family emergency cited)
*** PLEASE NOTE***
Because the city's new recording system does not allow us to see the vote, we are unable to claim 100% accuracy in our recording of each councillor's vote. Where we do indicate the vote breakdown, it is now based on how each councillor spoke to an issue during discussion or in media, and what votes our volunteers were able to see and record in the moment. Please share any errors with us and we will be happy to correct.
(We have made a request of City Hall to show the full council during votes, and have met with resistance so far.)
🧑⚖️🫅 Student Mayor(s)
Swearing In of incoming student mayor Mateo Gordon from Trillium Woods Elementary School
📜📜 Confirmation of the Minutes
Minutes from October 30: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554409&GUID=E2B10EE8-8965-4C0D-81E9-747B7F4E6738
🏆🏅 Awards and Recognitions
⚾️🥇 8UAA Rep Barrie Baycats
Winners of the Ontario Baseball Association (OBA) Championship
🎄🧑🎨 2024 Mayor's Christmas Card Contest Winner
📑🗂 Reports from Officers
Nil
🗣🎙 Deputations
🚫🏢 Zoning Bylaw Amendment Application - 19 Dundonald Street (Ward 2)
Deputation Requests: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13558009&GUID=E315DB63-7BB6-4362-B410-0F8699A378C6
Charles Beihn (a neighbour of the site, speaking in favour of the denial)
Michael Larkin (a professional planner, speaking in favour of the denial)
💸⚖️ Tax Applications
Applications: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554408&GUID=E1299823-CB9B-40E9-B874-AA60CB2E80B3
Application for cancellation, reduction or addition to taxes in the amount of $54,244.16
APPROVED (presumed unanimously)
📝📄 General Committee Report
Report from November 13: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554415&GUID=DD1B7A52-F439-4E6A-9583-9A1078AE1D06
Section A (reports received)
🚸🚨 Community Safety Committee
Report from October 30: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531941&GUID=14737A83-2638-4A6A-A021-723E290D8FED
RECEIVED (presumed unanimously)
Section B (consent items)
APPROVED (presumed unanimously)
🌳🛝 Parks Strategic Plan Update
Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531928&GUID=C088E3F4-5235-4AA1-AD01-684D714CDB86
Approve the Parkland Needs Assessment as the "Parks Plan"
Proceed on the plan in 2025 with $385,000 approved in the Capital Business Plan to be funded by the Cash-in-Lieu Parkland Reserve
🏘️🏘️ Zoning Bylaw Amendment Application - 830, 864, 912 Lockhart Road (Ward 10)
Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531920&GUID=8D63F699-0247-4F25-878A-7FD85AECA565
Approve the rezoning from 'Agricultural General' (AG) and 'Environmental Protection' (EP) (Innisfil) to 'Neighbourhood Residential' (R5), 'Environmental Protection' (EP) and 'Open Space' (OS)
This change is to facilitate a development of 338 residential building lots including single detached and townhouse dwellings
🚶🚷 Andean Lane Sidewalk Removal Feasibility (Ward 7)
Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531923&GUID=E55DA1D8-548B-4E67-B8B0-303FC1D7A11B
Receive the report (which recommends not removing the sidewalk)
🚶🚸 Intersection Safety Investigation - Anne Street North and Hanmer Street West (Ward 4)
Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531924&GUID=0DEE6BAA-4AA5-4C06-9C88-C899586E86D6
Receive the report (which recommended making no changes)
🤐🏷️ Confidential Property Acquisition Matter - Business Attraction
Receive the Employment Lands Strategy Update 2024 (as provided in the confidential staff report)
Direct staff to prioritize strategies for the development of employment lands, investment attraction and business growth by:
incentivization through the development of an Employment Lands Development Community Improvement Plan (CIP)
investigation of options for the acquisition and/or cooperative development of employment lands parcels
consideration of opportunities for further advancement of capital projects in the Capital Plan to unlock potential employment lands development opportunities
Direct the Economic and Creative Development Department to proceed with the public consultation process for the development of an Employment Lands Development CIP based on the proposed framework presented in the confidential staff report, including scheduling the required statutory public meeting as soon as possible, and report back to General Committee in early 2025 with recommendations, including funding and resource requirements
Direct the Economic and Creative Development Department to further investigate the options and considerations for the acquisition and/or cooperative development of employment land parcels, as presented in the confidential staff report, and report back to General Committee with development and fiscal considerations as required
Give the Chief Administrative Officer authority to allocate up to $100,000 from the Commercial/Industrial Lands Reserve to conduct any preliminary environmental and/or technical analysis related to the acquisition and/or cooperative development of employment land parcels as presented in the confidential staff report
🎡💵 Tourism Barrie and City of Barrie - Municipal Accommodation Tax (MAT) Collection Agreement Renewal and Update of Associated Bylaws
Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531942&GUID=7F66ECAD-7045-4698-8421-2E794811F7AF
Update the collection agreement to reflect an increase to the MAT from 4% to 6%, under following terms and conditions:
Tourism Barrie continues to receive 50% of the MAT
Agreement to be five years, expiring March 31, 2029, with option to extend for another five, subject to approval of Council
Inclusion of Tourism Barrie's commitment to provide 50% of their half of the 2% MAT increase to the City's to be allocated to the Sadlon Arena Expansion Reserve
Keep the same general terms and conditions as the present agreement, under the following principles:
must adhere to all applicable law under the Municipal Act
remittances to be received on a quarterly basis with a verified summary from Tourism Barrie
their donated half of the 2% MAT increase will be remitted semi-anually
appropriate fiscal accountability, audit requirements, inspection powers, termination provisions and other requirements to ensure appropriate accountability and oversight
commitment of Tourism Barrie to continue to support strategic initiatives with the City within the tourism sector in alignment with the Tourism Master Plan
Amend the Bylaws to align with current municipal best practices with the following changes:
address adding arrears of the MAT, interest and penalties to the tax roll for the properties registered in the name of the Provider, collected as property taxes
include actions available to Chief Financial Officer for MAT, penalties and interest that are past due and in arrears
include the definition of those guilty of an offence under the bylaw
revise penalties for those found to be guilty of an offence under the bylaw
Section C (presentation received)
RECEIVED (presumed unanimously)
💰🧑💻 Value For Money Service Audit
Presentation: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531921&GUID=6F0AFF73-C867-4EC0-8956-7D487BBB886F
Final report from auditors, investigating the value for service of the current service agreement with the County
The report put an end to the frequent Council complaint that Barrie is being under-serviced by its agreement with the County, and recommends that the City is better off continuing the partnership - however, the mayor appeared to "move the goalposts", saying it didn't give the information he was looking for (even though all the information asked for was given)
Section D
APPROVED (presumed unanimously)
💰🧑💻 Value for Money Service Audit Report
Staff Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531922&GUID=DA237D14-427E-49EE-A609-B20A140AA8F1
Audit Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531943&GUID=AD8543EA-630C-4BC6-B52D-8E83D33E95E3
Receive the report for information
Direct staff to consider Deloitte's recommendations regarding the capital allocation method, in the negotiation of the new Municipal Services Management Agreement with the County
Section E
⁉️📋 Additional Information on Key Performance Indicators for Council's 2022-2026 Strategic Plan
Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531919&GUID=5523CF60-787C-471C-A50E-45968EA57166
Receive the report for information purposes
AMENDMENT by Hamilton: delete paragraph 1 and replace it with "That the Key Performance Indicators for Council's 2022-2026 Strategic Plan be amended as follows: Under 'Community Safety' by adding the KPI 'reduction in crash rate for highest-rating intersections and road segments', by adding the KPI 'percent implementation of Community Safety and Well-being Plan', by removing the KPI 'number of Code inspections'; under 'Infrastructure Investment' by adding the KPI 'Infrastructure Capital Plan amount approved and amounts spent', 'actual capital spending as a percentage of total budget', and by reporting the KPI related to 'total kilometers of paving for new road lanes' separately for construction and resurfacing, and under 'Responsible Governance' by adding the KPI 'total cost avoidance associated with continuous improvement initiatives'
Amendment CARRIED [FOR: Nigussie, Harvey, Harris, Morales, Hamilton; AGAINST: Kungl, Courser - these are all assumed, based on the discussion, remaining did not speak]
MOTION, as amended, CARRIED [no discussion, cannot guess on breakdown]
Section F
🚫🏢 Zoning Bylaw Amendment Application - 19 Dundonald Street (Ward 2)
Report: https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13531927&GUID=5A9C5564-C49B-4AB0-A929-BEDBB92CEAC1
Deny the Zoning Amendment
CARRIED [assuming all 'for' but Morales, as last week]
⏸️⏯️ Deferred Business
Nil
➡️📜 Direct Motions
🍻⛱️ Pilot Patio Program - Flying Monkeys Brewery/Restaurant
Moved By: Nixon / Nigussie
Issue a Right of Way Permit in support of a pilot patio program allowing Flying Monkeys Brewery / Restaurant to have their patio remain open until April 14, 2025, at a reduced allowance of 8 feet from the building, at which time an updated permit for the summer / fall season will be issued
All other provisions within the Business Licensing Bylaw and Snow Clearing (Downtown) Bylaw remain in effect
Staff to review the outcome of this pilot program to determine any operational impacts for potential continuation or expansion and report back to the Infrastructure and Community Investment Committee or General Committee
AMENDMENT by Nixon: delete paragraph 1 and replace it with: "That notwithstanding business licensing bylaw 2006-266 as amended, staff issue the following: a right-of-way permit in support of a pilot patio program allowing Flying Monkeys Brewery / Restaurant to have their patio remain open until April 14th, 2025, at a reduced allowance of 8 feet from the building, at which time an updated permit for the summer / fall season will be issued, and up to two additional right-of-way permits to support two additional patios to open between March 15, 2025 and April 14, 2025, at a reduced allowance of 8 feet from the building, at which time an updated permit for the summer / fall season will be issued.
Amendment CARRIED [no way to determine vote breakdown]
MOTION, as amended, CARRIED: [FOR: Kungl, Courser, Harvey, Harris, Morales, Hamilton - camera did go wide partway through vote, did not show Nixon's hand up, but we can presume he voted in favour, likely Nigussie as well, unsure of Riepma, but because Nixon & Nigussie's hands were already down, he may have been in favour as well]
🧑🏫📑 Presentations
Nil
📜📜 Bylaws
🛣️🚰 Bill 119 - Yonge GO Village Acceptance of Municipal Services Phase 1 - Fairlane Avenue, Gateland Drive, Turnberry Lane, South Park Lane, Westwood Avenue
Accept the "as-constructed" municipal services within and complementary to Phase 1 of the Yonge-GO Village subdivision, and to assume the streets within this plan of subdivision for public use
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554398&GUID=0580CA40-AB9F-4FFA-B133-AE38889E3F79
🏘️🗺️ Bill 120 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 15 & 17 Hampton Lane
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554399&GUID=062C7579-F66A-42DB-9C09-9415D555FC49
🏘️🗺️ Bill 121 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 1 to 13 Hampton Lane, odd numbers
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554400&GUID=4D940C75-E48F-4A15-A14C-82B23FD0A3E4
🏘️🗺️ Bill 122 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 2 to 16 Hampton Lane, even numbers
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554401&GUID=E7497FEB-7C57-4265-B0D3-2368FC49238D
🏘️🗺️ Bill 123 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 1 to 15 Pearen Lane, odd numbers, and 2 to 16 Ennerdale Street, even numbers
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554402&GUID=7642CA1A-FCF9-47FC-A9B5-BAFF8B8F5EAD
🏘️🗺️ Bill 124 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 17 to 27 Pearen Lane, odd numbers, and 18 to 28 Ennerdale Street, even numbers
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554407&GUID=0DABC501-E9E1-43A9-B914-98828ADCAFF1
🏘️🗺️ Bill 125 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 29 to 43 Pearen Lane, odd numbers, and 30 to 44 Ennerdale Street, even numbers
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554406&GUID=EB278C35-8379-4903-B975-91C11A88517C
🏘️🗺️ Bill 126 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 76 to 86 Pearen Lane, even numbers
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554405&GUID=E7B71722-3D4E-4DEF-9260-6A45E0AD3AA7
🏘️🗺️ Bill 127 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 60 to 74 Pearen Lane, even numbers
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554404&GUID=1F13EF94-10D9-466C-89D5-643BEF7715EC
🏘️🗺️ Bill 128 - Part Lot Control Exemption - 48 to 58 Pearen Lane, even numbers
Remove the properties from Part Lot Control
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554403&GUID=08F80256-8465-41C1-9890-41EBA493AB54
🏢🗺️ Bill 129 - Zoning Bylaw Amendment - 515 Big Bay Point Road
Rezone the property from 'Residential Single Detached Dwelling First Density' (R1) to 'General Commercial' (C4)
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554413&GUID=A5548264-1BCB-4A78-8009-D4D5889CF1D4
🏘️🗺️ Bill 130 - Zoning Bylaw Amendment - 830, 864 and 912 Lockhart Road
Rezone the property from 'Agricultural General' (AG) and 'Environmental Protection' (EP) to 'Neighbourhood Residential' (R5), 'Environmental Protection' (EP) and 'Open Space' (OS
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554414&GUID=9ED06760-769F-4D3A-AEF0-85BA673BD7E1
📸👮 Bill 131 - Administrative Penalty system for Automated Speed Enforcement
Appoint screening and hearing officers to administer an Administrative Penalty system for Automated Speed Enforcement within the municipality
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554412&GUID=9E048A79-4A64-4674-8FC4-5F0AD5C806D2
🚫🏎️ Bill 132 - Amendments - Administrative Penalty Bylaw
Enhance compliance with the bylaws respecting the speed of vehicles in Community Safety and School zones through an Administrative Penalty System within the municipality
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554410&GUID=D425AE42-265F-4951-AD1A-E9902463D1F2
Bill 133 - Confirmation Bylaw
Confirming the meeting's proceedings
https://barrie.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=13554411&GUID=7C763CBB-53CF-4C31-8583-377B3E803C74
Comments